Commercial lines - fire, burglary, business interruption - are evaluated differently from personal lines. Premium matters, but claim-time experience matters more. A ₹2,000 saving with an insurer that disputes every stock claim is not a saving - it is a trap.
| Insurer | Commercial lines CSR (FY 2023-24)* | Solvency ratio | Indicative package premium (₹20L SI) | Strength |
|---|
| New India Assurance | 96.8% | 1.58× | ₹4,200 | Largest commercial lines insurer; strong surveyor network in Tier 2/3 |
| United India Insurance | 95.6% | 1.43× | ₹3,800 | Strong rural/semi-urban presence; competitive for low-risk trades |
| Oriental Insurance | 96.1% | 1.52× | ₹4,000 | PSU reliability; bank-mandated and government premises |
| HDFC ERGO | 94.9% | 1.92× | ₹5,500 | Fast digital claims; EEI and cyber add-ons |
| Bajaj Allianz | 96.2% | 3.52× | ₹4,800 | High solvency; solid shopkeeper package for mid-market retail |
| Tata AIG | 93.8% | 1.82× | ₹5,200 | Strong for premium retail, hotels, restaurants |
*Premiums are indicative for a low-risk retail shop (garments/kirana), ₹20L sum insured, ground floor, metro city. Actual premiums vary significantly by trade type, city, floor, security measures, and construction type. Source: IRDAI Annual Report 2023–24 (illustrative).
Surveyor network quality
Commercial claims use licensed loss assessors. For large claims (above ₹25 lakhs), you have the right to appoint your own independent licensed surveyor. Insurers with stronger surveyor networks in your city mean faster appointments and faster settlements.
Policy wording quality
Core SFSP wording is IRDAI-mandated, but endorsements, add-ons, and sub-limits differ. Ask for the full policy wording before purchase - not just the schedule. Pay attention to stock in trade definitions and how stock is valued at claim time.
PSU vs private insurer
PSU insurers (e.g. New India, United India, Oriental) often have wider physical reach in smaller cities - important when you need a local surveyor quickly. Private insurers can be faster in metros with digital claims. Choose based on your geography, not premium alone.
Claims documentation support
Most commercial claim failures are documentation problems - missing invoices, incomplete stock registers, no fire brigade report. Insurers that assign a dedicated claims contact for commercial clients often outperform those that leave shop owners to figure it out alone.